Child Safety Identification
In today's society, DNA technology is so overwhelmingly consumer friendly and present in the media, one would think that DNA would be collected
immediately at the notice or mention of a missing person. According to
statistics, every 26 seconds another child becomes lost or missing. Did you
know that nearly 2,000,000 American children are kidnapped, lost, missing or
run away every year?
However, in many states it is not law, or common practice for local
authorities to collect DNA samples from the home, family members or
personal possessions of a reported missing child or loved one until well into the event. In fact,
it was only less than one year ago that the State of New Jersey enacted Patricia's Law which allows for the collection of a reference DNA sample, 30
days after a reported missing child or loved one, if the missing person is not considered high risk.
Many parents and legal guardians, living in the bucolic towns of New Jersey,
have the "not in my town" ideology. The routine
"fingerprint and photograph day" at the local "stranger danger" seminars are considered to be enough when it comes to protecting
children. Why not take advantage of the newest technology (DNA Typing)
to protect children and track/trace them in the nightmarish event of
abduction or loss. Baby boomers live in a sandwich generation, where we are taking care of children as well as our senior adults parents. DNA Typing of an individual provides comfort knowing that if that person becomes lost or missing, you have a DNA profile available to provide to the local authorities (rather than waiting for them) to assist in their search for your missing child or loved one.
Here is a brief outline of Patricia's Law,
Introduction
The key points of
"Patricia's Law" are as follows:
- A law enforcement
agency shall accept without delay any report of a missing person and cannot
refuse to accept such reports for any reason.
- Provides a detailed
breakout of the specific information to be gathered and recorded by law
enforcement about the missing person.
- After 30 days missing,
ensures that a DNA reference sample is secured from the family of the missing
person and forwarded to the appropriate agency for analysis and ultimately
entry into CODIS (mp) , the Combined DNA Index System for Missing Persons, to
check for a match. Once the DNA profile is available, the missing persons
record in the National Crime Information System (NCIC), will be updated to
reflect that DNA is available.
- Improves the system of
communication between law enforcement and the person making the report,
a family member, or any other person in a position to assist law enforcement in
locating the missing person, including informing the person filing the missing
persons report of the existence of two clearing houses for missing person's
information. If the person reported missing is age 17 or under, the
person filing the report shall be provided with contact information for the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children. If the person reported missing is age 18
or older, the person filing the report shall be provided with contact
information for the National Center for
Missing Adults.
- Law enforcement shall
immediately determine if the missing person is deemed "high-risk" and
will take immediate action. The NJ State Police Missing Persons Unit
resources will be available as needed.
- The Attorney General
will provide information to local law enforcement concerning best practices and
protocols for handling death scene investigations.
- Improve procedures for
handling human remains and communication with the family.
In the Northeast, we are all familiar with the events of 911. DNA was used to help identify the victims who were lost in the attack. "DNA was used when other technologies, such as the use of fingerprints, surgical scars and dental records could not be employed. DNA helped bring closure to countless families who suffered the loss of loved ones and might not have otherwise been able to find the closure they so desperately needed." (Source: Sara Kugler, DNA Identifies Trade Center Victims, October 24, 2001 (Associated Press)
Complete latest version of Patricia Law
SENATE, No. 2255
STATE OF NEW JERSEY
212th LEGISLATURE
INTRODUCED OCTOBER 16, 2006
Sponsored by:
Senator LORETTA WEINBERG
District 37 (Bergen)
SYNOPSIS
"Patricia's Law;" model Missing Persons Legislation.
CURRENT VERSION OF TEXT
As reported by the Senate Budget and Appropriations Committee on June
18, 2007, with amendments.
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
2
EXPLANATION - Matter enclosed in bold-faced brackets [thus] in the above bill is
not enacted and is intended to be omitted in the law.
Matter underlined thus is new matter.
Matter enclosed in superscript numerals has been adopted as follows:
1Senate SLP committee amendments adopted February 26, 2007.
2Senate SBA committee amendments adopted June 18, 2007.
AN ACT concerning missing 1 persons, designating the act as
2 "Patricia's Law," and supplementing Title 52 of the Revised
3 Statutes.
4
5 BE IT ENACTED by the Senate and General Assembly of the State
6 of New Jersey:
7
8 1. As used in this act:
19 "High risk missing person" means a person whose whereabouts
are not currently known and the circumstances 210 [indicate] of the
person's disappearance suggest2 11 that the person may be at
2imminent or likely2 12 risk of injury or death. The circumstances that
indicate that a person is a 2[high-risk] high risk2 13 missing person
14 shall include, but not be limited to:
a. the person is missing as a result of a 2[stranger] confirmed2 15
abduction 216 [;
b. the person is missing under suspicious] or under2 17
circumstances 218 that indicate that the person's disappearance was not
voluntary2 19 ;
220 [c. the person is missing under unknown circumstances;
d.] b.2 21 the person is missing under known dangerous
22 circumstances;
2[e.] c.2 23 The person is missing more than 30 days;
224 [f. the person has already been designated as a high-risk
25 missing person by another law enforcement agency;
g.] d.2 26 there is evidence that the person is at risk because:
(1) the person missing is in need of medical attention 2[,]2 27 or
prescription medication 228 such that it will have a serious adverse
29 effect on the person's health if he or she does not receive the
needed care or medication2 30 ;
31 (2) the person missing does not have a pattern of running away
32 or disappearing;
33 (3) the person missing may have been abducted by a non34
custodial parent;
35 (4) the person missing is mentally impaired;
(5) the person missing is a person 2over the age of 13 and2 36
under the age of 21 years 2and any other risk factor is known2 37 or
38 (6) the person missing has been the subject of past threats or
acts of violence 2[.]2 39 ; and
2[h. ] e.2 40 any other factor that may indicate, in the judgment
of the 2[chief of the] lead2 law enforcement agency, 241 [receiving
the missing person report,]2 that the missing person may be at risk.1 42
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
3
"Law enforcement agency" 1 means a department, division,
bureau, commission, board 2,2 2 or other authority of the State or of
3 any political subdivision thereof which employs law enforcement
4 officers.
5 "Law enforcement officer" means a person whose public duties
6 include the power to act as an officer for the detection,
apprehension, arrest 2, 2 7 and conviction of offenders against the
8 laws of this State.
29 "Lead law enforcement agency" means the law enforcement
10 agency with primary responsibility for investigating a missing
11 person case.
12 "Missing child" means a person 13 years of age or younger
13 whose whereabouts are not currently known.
14 "Missing Persons Unit" means the Missing Persons Unit in the
15 Division of State Police in the Department of Law and Public
16 Safety established pursuant to section 2 of P.L.1983, c.467
(C.52:17B-9.7).2 17
18
2. 2a.2 19 A law enforcement agency shall accept without delay
20 any report of a missing person. No law enforcement agency may
21 refuse to accept a missing person report on the basis that:
2[a.] (1)2 22 The missing person is an adult;
2[b.] (2)2 23 The circumstances do not indicate foul play;
2[c.] (3)2 24 The person has been missing for a short period of
25 time;
2[d.] (4)2 The person has been missing 1for1 26 a long period of
27 time;
2[e.] (5)2 28 There is no indication that the missing person was in
29 the jurisdiction served by the law enforcement agency at the time of
30 the disappearance;
2[f.] (6)2 31 The circumstances suggest that the disappearance
32 may be voluntary;
2[g] (7)2 The 1[person]1 reporting 1person1 33 does not have
34 personal knowledge of the facts;
2[h] (8)2. The reporting 1[individual] person135 cannot provide
36 all of the information requested by the law enforcement agency;
2[i.] (9)2 37 The reporting person lacks a familial or other
38 relationship with the missing person; or
2[j.] (10)2 39 For any other reason, except in cases where the law
40 enforcement agency has direct knowledge that the person is, in fact,
not missing and the exact whereabouts and welfare of the 241 [subject
individual] person2 42 are known to the agency at the time the report
43 is being made.
244 b. The law enforcement agency that receives a report of a
45 missing person shall be the lead law enforcement agency in charge
46 of the missing person investigation, and shall continue in that
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
4
capacity unless another law enforcement 1 agency assumes primary
2 responsibility over the investigation.
3 c. The lead law enforcement agency shall be entitled to the
cooperation of any other law enforcement agency in the State.2 4
5
3. At the time 1[of]1 6 a missing person report is filed, the law
7 enforcement agency shall seek to ascertain and record the following
8 information about the missing person:
a. The name of the missing person, including any aliases 1;1 9
10 b. Date of birth;
c. Identifying marks, such as birthmarks, moles, tattoos 2,2 11 and
12 scars;
13 d. Height and weight;
14 e. Gender;
15 f. Race;
16 g. Current hair color and true or natural hair color;
17 h. Eye color;
18 i. Prosthetics, surgical implants, or cosmetic implants;
19 j. Physical anomalies;
20 k. Blood type, if known;
21 l. Any medications the missing person is taking or needs to
22 take;
23 m. Driver's license number, if known;
24 n. Social security number, if known;
25 o. A recent photograph of the missing person, if available;
26 p. A description of the clothing the missing person was
27 believed to be wearing at the time of disappearance;
28 q. A description of notable items that the missing person may
29 be carrying and wearing;
r. Information 1[on] regarding1 30 the missing person's
31 electronic communications devices, such as a cell phone number or
2[email addresses] e-mail address232 ;
33 s. The reasons why the reporting person believes that the
34 person is missing;
t. 1[Name] The name1 and location of 1the1 35 missing person's
36 school or employer, if known;
u. 1[Name] The name1 and location of 1the1 37 missing person's
38 dentist and primary care physician, if known;
39 v. Any circumstances that may indicate that the disappearance
40 was not voluntary;
41 w. Any circumstances that indicate that the missing person may
42 be at risk of injury or death;
43 x. A description of the possible means of transportation of the
44 missing person, such as the make, model, color, license, and
2[VIN] Vehicle Identification Number (VIN)2 45 of a motor vehicle;
46 y. Any identifying information about a known or possible
47 abductor or the person last seen with the missing person including:
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
5
1 (1) name;
(2) 2[a]2 2 physical description;
3 (3) date of birth;
4 (4) identifying marks;
(5) 2[the]2 5 description of possible means of transportation, such
as the make, model, color, license, and 26 [VIN] Vehicle
Identification Number (VIN)2 7 of a motor vehicle; and
8 (6) known associates;
z. Any other information that can aid in 1[location] locating1 9
10 the missing person; and
11 aa. Date of last contact.
12
13 4. a. The law enforcement agency shall notify the person
14 making the report, a family member, or any other person in a
15 position to assist the law enforcement agency in its efforts to locate
16 the missing person by providing to that person or family member:
17 (1) general information about the handling of the missing person
18 case or about intended efforts in the case to the extent that the law
19 enforcement agency determines that disclosure would not adversely
20 affect its ability to locate or protect the missing person, to
21 apprehend or to prosecute any persons criminally involved in the
22 disappearance;
(2) information advising the person making the report 1[,]1 23 and
24 other involved persons that if the missing person remains missing,
they 2[1shall1] should2 25 contact the law enforcement agency to
26 provide additional information and materials that will aid in
27 locating the missing person, such as any credit or debit cards the
28 missing person has access to, other banking or financial information
29 and any records of cell phone use;
30 (3) in those cases where DNA samples are requested, the law
31 enforcement agency shall notify the person or family member that
32 all such DNA samples are provided on a voluntary basis and shall
33 be used solely to help locate or identify the missing person and shall
not be used for any other purpose; 2and2 34
35 (4) the law enforcement agency, upon acceptance of a missing
36 person report, shall inform the person filing the report that there are
37 two clearing houses for missing person's information. If the person
38 reported missing is age 17 or under, the person filing the report
39 shall be provided with contact information for the National Center
40 for Missing and Exploited Children. If the person reported missing
41 is age 18 or older, the person filing the report shall be provided with
42 contact information for the National Center for Missing Adults.
43 b. If the person identified in the missing person report remains
44 missing for 30 days, and the additional information and materials
45 specified below have not been received, the law enforcement
agency shall attempt to obtain 2[;] :2 46
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
6
(1) DNA samples from family members 1 and, if possible, from
2 the missing person along with any needed documentation, including
any consent forms, required for the use of State or 2[Federal] 3
federal2 4 DNA databases;
5 (2) dental information and x-rays, and an authorization to
6 release dental or skeletal x-rays of the missing person;
7 (3) any additional photographs of the missing person that may
8 aid the investigation or an identification. The law enforcement
9 agency shall not be required to obtain written authorization before it
10 releases publicly any photograph that would aid in the investigation
11 or identification of the missing person; and
12 (4) fingerprints.
c. All DNA samples obtained in missing 1[person's] persons1 13
14 cases shall be immediately forwarded to the New Jersey Forensic
15 DNA Laboratory for analysis. The laboratory shall establish
16 procedures for determining how to prioritize analysis of the samples
relating to missing persons cases 1[;] .1 17
18 d. Information relevant to the Federal Bureau of Investigation's
19 Violent Criminal Apprehension Program shall be entered as soon as
20 possible.
21 e. Nothing is this section shall be construed to preclude a law
22 enforcement agency from obtaining any of the materials identified
23 in this section before the 30th day following the filing of the
24 missing person report.
25
5. 1a.1 26 Upon the initial receipt of a missing person report, a law
27 enforcement agency shall seek to determine whether the person
reported missing is 2to be designated2 1a1 high risk 128 missing
person129 .
130 [a. A high-risk missing person is an individual whose
31 whereabouts are not currently known and the circumstances indicate
32 that the individual may be at risk of injury or death. The
33 circumstances that indicate that an individual is high-risk missing
34 person shall include, but not be limited to:
35 (1) the person is missing as a result of a stranger abduction;
36 (2) the person is missing under suspicious circumstances;
37 (3) the person is missing under unknown circumstances;
38 (4) the person is missing under known dangerous circumstances;
39 (5) the person is missing more than 30 days;
40 (6) the person has already been designated as a high-risk
41 missing person by another law enforcement agency;
42 (7) there is evidence that the person is at risk because:
43 (a) the person missing is in need of medical attention, or
44 prescription medication;
45 (b) the person missing does not have a pattern of running away
46 or disappearing;
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
7
(c) the person missing may ha 1 ve been abducted by a non2
custodial parent;
3 (d) the person missing is mentally impaired;
4 (e) the person missing is a person under the age of 21 years; or
5 (f) the person missing has been the subject of past threats or
6 acts of violence.
7 (8) any other factor that may, in the judgment of the chief of the
8 law enforcement agency receiving the missing person report,
determine that the missing person may be at risk.]1 9
b. 210 [A finding that a person reported missing is not] If the
11 initial determination of a person reported missing does not warrant
designation of that person as2 high risk 2, it2 12 shall not preclude a
13 later determination, based on further investigation or the discovery
14 of additional information, that the missing person is high risk.
15
6. a. 216 [When a law enforcement agency determines] Upon a
determination2 that a missing person 2[is] investigation involves2 17 a
1[high-risk] high risk1 missing person 218 [it shall notify the State
19 Police Missing Persons Unit. It shall immediately provide the State
20 Police Missing Persons Unit with the information that is most likely
to aid in the location and safe return of the 1[high-risk] high risk1 21
22 missing person. As soon as practicable, the law enforcement
23 agency shall provide all other information obtained relating to the
24 missing person case to the State Police Missing Persons Unit] or a
25 missing child, the lead law enforcement agency shall take such
26 actions as are specified in the uniform investigative standards for a
27 high risk missing person or a missing child, as the case may be, as
28 set forth in the protocol developed pursuant to section 10 of P.L. ,
29 c. (C. )(pending before the Legislature as this bill), and also
30 may contact the Missing Persons Unit and request assistance. The
31 Missing Persons Unit, in consultation with the lead law
32 enforcement agency, shall determine whether the circumstances
33 warrant a cooperative investigative effort. If the determination is
34 made that a cooperative effort is warranted, then the Missing
35 Persons Unit shall coordinate the deployment of additional State
Police resources in support of the investigation236 .
b. The 237 [State Police Missing Persons Unit] lead law
enforcement agency2 38 shall promptly notify all law enforcement
39 agencies within the State and, if deemed appropriate, law
40 enforcement agencies in adjacent states or jurisdictions of the
41 information that may aid in the prompt location and safe return of
the 1[high-risk] high risk1 missing person 2[;] .2 42
43 c. Local law enforcement agencies that receive notification
from the 244 [State Police Missing Unit] lead law enforcement
agency2 45 pursuant to subsection b. of this section shall forward that
46 information immediately to its officers and members.
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
8
d. 2The lead law enforcement agency shall, 1 as expeditiously as
2 possible, prepare and disseminate a photographic information
3 bulletin utilizing the Missing Child Alert System, or any successor
4 law enforcement notification system the State may employ,
e.2 The 25 [State Police Missing Persons Unit] lead law
enforcement agency2 6 shall, as appropriate, enter all collected
7 information relating to the missing person case to applicable
2[Federal] federal2 8 databases. The information shall be provided in
9 accordance with applicable guidelines relating to the databases, as
10 follows:
11 (1) a missing person report, and relevant information, in a
1[high-risk] high risk1 12 missing person case shall be entered in the
13 National Crime Information Center database immediately, but in no
case no more than 1[2] two1 hours 1[of] after1 14 the determination
that the missing person is a 1[high-risk] high risk1 15 missing person
2[.] ;2 16
17 (2) a missing person report, and relevant information, in a case
18 not involving a high risk missing person shall be entered within 24
hours of the initial filing of the missing person report 2[.] ;2 19
20 (3) all DNA profiles shall be uploaded into the missing persons
21 databases of the New Jersey Forensic DNA Laboratory and all
appropriate and suitable federal database systems 2[.] ;2 22
23 (4) information relevant to the Federal Bureau of Investigation's
24 Violent Criminal Apprehension Program shall be entered as soon as
practicable 2[.] ;2 25
26 (5) all due care shall be given to insure that the data, particularly
27 medical and dental records, entered in State and federal database
28 systems is accurate and, to the greatest extent possible, complete
2[.] ; and2 29
30 (6) the State Police shall, when deemed appropriate and likely to
31 facilitate a resolution to a particular missing person report, activate
32 the Amber Alert program for the State.
233 f. If, after the dissemination of a photographic information
34 bulletin utilizing the Missing Child Alert System information, the
35 missing person is found, the lead law enforcement agency shall
36 promptly disseminate an additional bulletin on the Missing Child
Alert System indicating that the person was found.2 37
38
39 7. a. The Attorney General shall provide information to local
40 law enforcement agencies about best practices and protocols for
handling death scene investigations 1[;] .1 41
42 b. The Attorney General shall identify any publications or
43 training opportunities that may be available to local law
44 enforcement officers concerning the handling of death scene
45 investigations.
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
9
8. a. After performing any 1 death scene investigation, as
2 deemed appropriate under the circumstances, the official with
3 custody of the human remains shall ensure that the human remains
4 are delivered to the appropriate county medical examiner.
5 b. Any county medical examiner with custody of human
6 remains that are not identified within 24 hours of discovery shall
promptly notify the 2[State Police] Missing Persons Unit2 7 of the
8 location of those remains.
9 c. If the county medical examiner with custody of remains
10 cannot determine whether or not the remains found are human, the
medical examiner shall so notify the 211 [State Police] Missing
Persons Unit212 .
13
14 9. a. If the official with custody of the human remains is not a
15 medical examiner, the official shall promptly transfer the
16 unidentified remains to the appropriate county medical examiner.
17 b. The county medical examiner shall make reasonable
18 attempts to promptly identify human remains. These actions may
19 include but are not limited to obtaining:
20 (1) photographs of the human remains;
21 (2) dental or skeletal X-rays;
22 (3) photographs of items found with the human remains;
23 (4) fingerprints from the remains, if possible;
24 (5) samples of tissue suitable for DNA typing, if possible;
(6) samples of whole bone 1[and/or] or1 25 hair suitable for DNA
typing; 1and1 26
27 (7) any other information that may support identification efforts.
c. No medical examiner or any other person shall 2[,]2 28 dispose
29 of, or engage in actions that will materially affect the unidentified
30 human remains before the county medical examiner obtains:
31 (1) samples suitable for DNA identification archiving;
32 (2) photographs of the unidentified human remains; and
33 (3) all other appropriate steps for identification have been
34 exhausted.
35 d. Unidentified human remains shall not be cremated.
36 e. The county medical examiner shall make reasonable efforts
to obtain prompt DNA analysis of biological samples 2[,]2 37 if the
38 human remains have not been identified by other means within 30
39 days.
40 f. The medical examiner shall seek support from appropriate
41 State and federal agencies to assist in the identification of
42 unidentified human remains. Such assistance may include, but not
43 be limited to, available mitochondrial or nuclear DNA testing,
44 federal grants for DNA testing, or federal grants for crime
45 laboratory or medical examiner office improvement.
g. The county medical examiner shall 246 seek support from
47 appropriate federal and State agency representatives to have
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
10
information2 promptly 2[enter information] 1 entered2 in federal and
State databases 2by those representatives2 2 that can aid in the
3 identification of a missing person. Information shall be entered into
4 federal databases as follows:
5 (1) information for the National Crime Information Center
6 within 24 hours;
7 (2) DNA profiles and information shall be entered into the
8 National DNA Index System (NDIS) within five business days after
9 the completion of the DNA analysis and procedures necessary for
10 the entry of the DNA profile; and
11 (3) information sought by the Violent Criminal Apprehension
12 Program database as soon as practicable.
13 h. Nothing in this act shall be construed to preclude any
14 medical examiner office, the State Police or any local law
15 enforcement agency from other actions to facilitate the
16 identification of unidentified human remains including efforts to
publicize information, descriptions 2,2 17 or photographs that may aid
18 in the identification of the unidentified remains, including allowing
19 family members to identify a missing person; provided that in
20 taking these actions, all due consideration is given to protect the
21 dignity and well-being of the of the missing person and the family
22 of the missing person.
23 i. Agencies handling the remains of a missing person who is
24 deceased shall notify the law enforcement agency handling the
missing person's case. Documented efforts 1[must] shall1 25 be made
26 to locate family members of the deceased person to inform them of
27 the death and location of the remains of their family member.
28
229 [10. The Attorney General, pursuant to the provisions of the
30 "Administrative Procedure Act," P.L.1968, c.410 (C.52:14B-1 et
31 seq.), shall promulgate rules and regulations to effectuate the
purposes of this act.]2 32
33
234 10. In implementing the provisions of this act and prior to the
35 effective date, the Superintendent of State Police shall develop and
36 disseminate to all law enforcement agencies in the State a best
37 practices protocol for State and local law enforcement agencies to
38 follow when addressing reports of missing persons, which protocol
39 shall set forth uniform investigative standards for missing persons
40 cases and any other procedures, practices and standards that the
41 superintendent deems appropriate for handling missing person
42 cases. The protocol shall include specific procedures practice and
43 standards applicable to cases involving high risk missing persons or
44 missing children. The Superintendent of State Police shall develop
45 and make available to each law enforcement agency in this State a
46 training program on the procedures, practices and standards for the
47 handling of high risk missing persons, missing children and missing
S2255 [2R] WEINBERG
11
persons cases set forth 1 in the protocol adopted pursuant to and
2 consistent with this act and section. Each law enforcement agency
3 in this State shall comply with this protocol when the agency is
4 notified of a missing person.
5 To assess the effectiveness of this protocol, the Missing Persons
6 Unit annually shall review a sample of open missing persons cases
7 from the immediately preceding year. Based upon its assessment,
8 the Missing Persons Unit may recommend to the superintendent that
9 the protocol be revised or amended and whether the training
10 programs currently available to law enforcement agencies are
adequate.2 11
12
13 11. This act shall take effect on the first day of the seventh
14 month following enactment, but the Attorney General may take
15 such anticipatory administrative action in advance as shall be
16 necessary for the implementation of this act.